Major retailers from Macy's to Sam's Club has a duty to offer customers and employees an acceptable amount of security from crime. Department stores and other big businesses can be held liable for failing to provide adequate protection.
- Assault and battery
- Rape and sexual misconduct
- Shootings and homicide
Were you or a loved one injured due to crime at a department store or other business? The experienced attorneys at Crime Victim Advocates want to help.
"A Committed Advocate" Brian knew more than every other attorney I contacted.
Wal-Mart. Target. JCPenney. Macy's. Nordstrom. Beyond their obvious similarities, every department store and big-box retailer in the United States also shares a legal obligation to provide paying customers and lawful visitors a reasonable measure of security against violent crime.
Filing A Third-Party Crime Lawsuit
Even so, numerous department store shoppers have suffered severe injuries when a criminal offender was able to circumvent a business' existing safety precautions to commit illegal and, in some cases, monstrous acts of violence.
The vast majority of these crimes take place in the parking lot, but a business' legal duty to customer, visitor and employee safety usually extends outside the store itself. Both outside in the parking lot and at the cashier's checkout counter, store shoppers are protected by a strong body of civil law that says negligent business owners can be held accountable for allowing violent crimes to occur.
It might seem implausible at first. Most crime victims understand that they have certain rights inside the criminal justice system. And some survivors of crime, including families who have lost a loved one to murder, know that it's possible, however difficult, to file a civil lawsuit against a criminal offender and demand financial compensation.
But suing the store, large or small, where the crime was committed? For some reason, that's counter-intuitive. It also happens to be possible in many cases.
Negligent Security Lawsuits Against Department Stores
Thousands of crime victims and families have secured financial compensation in the past by suing a department store that failed to provide them with adequate security.
Like the big-box retailers, from Wal-Mart and Sam's Club to IKEA, department stores have a legal obligation under state law to secure their properties against violent criminals. And most of these companies own the parking lots located adjacent to their warehouses, which means that their legal responsibilities carry out into the aisles of parked cars.
Store Liability Often Extends To Parking Lot
That's a very good thing for customers, who are often left most vulnerable when they're preoccupied by unloading or loading their vehicles. Carjackings, assault and battery, sexual attacks, even kidnapping and murder - every form of heinous crime imaginable has occurred at some point in a business' parking lot. It's particularly true in high-crime neighborhoods, a fact that the vast majority of courts will take into account in considering a negligent security lawsuit.
Anticipating Violent Crime & Taking Action
In most cases, property owners can only be held accountable for allowing "foreseeable" crimes to occur. Department stores can't be found liable for third-party crimes that they had no way to see coming. Nor could they adequately protect customers against a type of crime that no reasonable person would expect to occur on their property.
To determine whether or not a violent crime should be considered "foreseeable," the court will review the property's prior history of crime, along with the history of crime in the wider neighborhood.
Varying Patterns Of Crime
Businesses in high-crime areas usually have a higher duty to protect than stores in low-crime neighborhoods. And special safety requirements may hold at particular times of the day. When the sun sets, for example, the security needs for a parking lot change. Bright lights become a necessity, both to eliminate the shadows in which potential offenders can hide and deter criminals from committing violent acts. But no one would argue that, during the day, a properly-maintained lamp post would be able to prevent a violent crime.
What Can Department Stores Do To Prevent Crime?
In high-traffic areas, a team of trained security guards may be warranted, both to watch for potential crimes inside the store and to circle the parking lot. Outside of urban areas, on the other hand, security guards may not be necessary.
Parking lot and department store design is another important consideration. Both areas should be laid out in such a way that customers and employees have clear, unobstructed lines of sight. It probably goes without saying that a working and up-to-date security camera system is a must, especially at larger department stores that may be too big for any one employee to surveille adequately.
It's likely that the judge in a negligent security case will take all of these factors into consideration, hoping to understand the totality of circumstances that surrounded the crime before deciding whether or not the store should be found liable for financial damages.
Particular Crimes Deserve Particular Precautions
Judges also tend to get pretty specific. So when we talk about a "history of crime," we're really talking about a history of specific crimes. If three sexual assaults occur in the same parking lot, it seems reasonable that the lot's owner should ramp up the security to prevent further assaults. They might not have the same level of duty where kidnapping, murder or other crimes are concerned.
In the end, crime victims and families will have to prove that the department store's owner had a duty to maintain reasonable security precautions, but failed to meet that duty. Then, the store's failure will have to be tied to the particular crime at issue.
How A Civil Lawsuit Can Help Survivors & Families
Survivors often face significant struggles in the wake of suffering a violent crime. Many will be forced to overcome physical injuries, requiring days or weeks in the hospital and incurring large medical bills. The vast majority will also be affected by emotional trauma. And few will be able to return to work immediately, thus having to accept a loss in wages just when they need the money to cover their necessary treatments.
Unfortunately, the criminal justice system has never been particularly good at supporting victims and their families. In fact, before the last few decades, survivors of crime were usually treated as little more than human pieces of evidence. Today, the situation is better, but it's far from perfect. While state compensation funds offer necessary financing to hundreds of crime victims every year, these programs come with strict compensation limits and often impose onerous deadlines.
Contact Our Legal Team Now
The civil justice system provides survivors and their loved ones with a second avenue for legal recourse. By filing a negligent security lawsuit, you and your family can pursue valuable financial compensation and begin on the long road to recovery with confidence. Our experienced victims' advocates can help. To learn more about your rights and options, contact our lawyers today for a free consultation.